LVP vs Hardwood in Georgia Humidity: Which Floor Makes Sense for Your Home?
I'm Cristobal. I refinish and install hardwood floors around Atlanta, and I also put down a lot of luxury vinyl plank (LVP). Almost every week someone asks me the same question: with Georgia's humidity, should I go with LVP or real wood? There is no single answer, but there is a right answer for each room. Here is how I think about it when I walk through a house.
What Georgia humidity does to a floor
From June to September the air around Atlanta sits at 70 to 90 percent humidity on many days. Solid hardwood takes on that moisture and swells a little. In winter, when the heat runs, it dries out and shrinks. That is why you see thin gaps between boards in January that close up by summer. That movement is normal, and a floor that was installed with the right gap at the walls handles it fine.
The trouble starts when moisture comes from below. Many older homes in Kirkwood, Decatur and East Point sit on crawl spaces with no vapor barrier. Newer homes in places like Canton or Loganville are often on a slab in the basement. Too much moisture from the ground makes hardwood cup, with the edges of each board higher than the middle. LVP does not care about that moisture at all.
Where LVP wins
- Basements on a slab. Concrete holds moisture. I almost never put solid hardwood on a basement slab. LVP is my first choice there.
- Bathrooms and laundry rooms. Standing water and wet feet are hard on wood. Good LVP with a locking joint handles spills.
- Rentals and busy homes with big dogs. LVP resists scratches better than most site-finished oak, and a damaged plank can be swapped.
- Homes where you need the room back fast. LVP can be walked on the same day. A refinish needs a few days for the finish to dry.
Where hardwood wins
- Main living areas on a wood subfloor. Living rooms, dining rooms, halls and bedrooms on the main floor are where real wood shines, especially in the older homes around Buckhead, Vinings and East Cobb.
- Long-term value. Solid oak can be sanded and refinished many times over its life. When LVP wears out or goes out of style, it gets torn out and replaced.
- Matching what you already have. If half the house has oak, new oak woven in and refinished together looks like one floor. LVP next to oak always looks like two floors.
- Feel and sound. Wood feels warmer under your feet and sounds solid. Some LVP sounds hollow, especially over an uneven subfloor.
Engineered hardwood: the middle option
Engineered hardwood has a real wood top layer glued over plywood layers. It moves less than solid wood when the humidity changes, so it is a good choice for a slab on the main floor or a room where solid wood would be risky. Many engineered floors can be refinished once or twice if the wear layer is thick enough. I check that before I promise anything.
Fix the moisture first
Whatever floor you pick, the moisture problem under it does not go away. Before I install or refinish, I check the boards and the crawl space with a moisture meter. If the crawl space is wet, a vapor barrier or a dehumidifier comes first. If a hardwood floor is already cupping, I want to fix the cause before I sand it flat, or it comes right back. In summer I like to keep the house around 35 to 55 percent humidity with the AC running.
My honest take
If you already have hardwood under carpet or worn finish, refinishing it is usually the better choice than covering it with LVP. If you are doing a basement, a bathroom or a rental, LVP makes more sense. Many homes I work in end up with both: refinished oak upstairs and on the main floor, LVP in the basement. You can read more about how I refinish floors on my hardwood floor refinishing page, or see the work I do in Buckhead, Vinings and East Cobb.
Not sure which floor is right for your house? Call or text Cristobal at 404-796-7650 with a few photos of the rooms and I'll tell you what I would do.
Common questions
Can LVP be installed over my old hardwood?
Yes, but I usually suggest refinishing the hardwood instead. If the wood is solid and thick enough, sanding it brings it back for far less trouble than covering it up.
Will hardwood cup in a Georgia summer?
Not if the house is kept cool and the crawl space or slab is dry. Cupping almost always comes from moisture underneath, not from the air alone.
Is LVP waterproof?
The planks are, but water can still get under them through the edges and walls. A big leak still needs to be dried out.
Which one lasts longer?
Solid hardwood. It can be sanded and refinished many times over decades. LVP lasts until the wear layer wears through, then it gets replaced.
How much will each one cost?
It depends on square footage, the material you choose, repairs and stairs. Text me photos and the square footage and I'll give you an exact price.