How to Tell If Your Hardwood Floors Need Refinishing
I'm Cristobal, and I sand and refinish hardwood floors across metro Atlanta. A lot of calls start with the same question: "Do my floors really need refinishing, or am I just tired of looking at them?" Here are the signs I look for when I walk into a house, plus two quick tests you can do yourself before you call me at 404-796-7650.
1. The water drop test
Pour a tablespoon of water on a busy spot, like in front of the kitchen sink or the hallway to the back door. Watch it for 10 to 15 minutes.
- The water beads up: the finish is still sealing the wood. A deep clean or a screen and recoat is probably all you need.
- It soaks in slowly and darkens the wood a little: the finish is getting thin. A recoat soon will save you a full sanding later.
- It soaks in right away and leaves a dark spot: the finish is gone in that area and the wood is bare. That floor needs a full sand and refinish.
2. Gray or black boards
When the finish wears through, water and dirt get into the wood fibers and turn the boards gray. Black spots usually mean water sat there for a long time, often around pet bowls, plant pots, the dishwasher or an exterior door. Gray boards I can sand clean almost every time. Deep black stains sometimes go all the way through the board, and then I cut out those pieces and weave in matching oak.
3. Traffic lanes you can see from across the room
In most Atlanta homes the path from the front door to the kitchen wears first. If that lane looks dull and lighter than the edges of the room where the furniture sits, the finish has worn down there. Catch it early and a recoat blends it back. Wait too long and the wood itself starts to wear, and then only sanding fixes it.
4. Finish that peels, flakes or turns yellow
Older oil-based finishes in houses from the 1950s through the 1980s often turn amber or orange with age. Some people like that warm look. If you want it lighter, or the finish is peeling in sheets, a recoat won't stick. I sand it all back to bare wood and start fresh.
5. Scratches that go into the wood
Run your fingernail across a scratch. If your nail doesn't catch, the scratch is only in the finish, and a screen and recoat will hide it. If your nail catches and you can see raw wood at the bottom, the scratch is in the boards. Dogs, chairs without felt pads and grit from shoes cause most of these.
6. Cupping, gaps and Georgia humidity
Atlanta summers are humid, and many older homes in Decatur, Kirkwood, East Atlanta and Buckhead sit over crawlspaces. If the edges of your boards are higher than the middle, that is cupping, and it means moisture is coming from below. Refinishing won't fix that by itself. I check the moisture in the wood first. If it's too high, the crawlspace or the AC needs attention before I sand, or the boards will crown later. Small gaps that open in winter and close in summer are normal.
Refinish or recoat?
A screen and recoat means I lightly buff the old finish and put a fresh coat on top. It works when the finish is worn but the wood under it is still clean, with no gray spots. It takes about a day.
A full refinish means I sand to bare wood in three passes, fix damaged boards, stain if you want a new color, and put on three coats of finish. It's the right choice when you see gray or black wood, deep scratches, peeling finish, or you want a different color. Most jobs take 3 to 5 days.
Can my floor be sanded again?
Solid 3/4 inch oak, the most common floor in Atlanta homes, can be sanded many times. Engineered hardwood has a thinner top layer, so I check it first by pulling a floor vent and looking at the edge of the board. If the top layer is too thin, I'll tell you a recoat is the safer choice.
You can read about my whole process on my hardwood floor refinishing page, or see the homes I work on in Buckhead and Vinings.
Call or text Cristobal at 404-796-7650. Send me a few photos of the worn spots and I'll tell you honestly whether you need a full refinish or just a recoat.
Common questions
How often should hardwood floors be refinished?
In most Atlanta homes, a full refinish lasts 7 to 10 years. A screen and recoat every 3 to 5 years in busy areas can stretch that a lot longer.
Can I refinish just one room?
Yes, but the new finish may look a little different next to the old one. I usually suggest stopping at a doorway or a threshold so the change looks clean.
Is the floor under my carpet worth refinishing?
Very often, yes. Many Atlanta houses built before the 1970s have oak under the carpet. Pull up a corner in a closet and text me a photo.
How much does refinishing cost?
It depends on the square footage, the stain, any board repairs and how many stairs there are. Text me photos and the square footage and I'll give you an exact price.